BetaWe're testing this book with small groups. Your answers and statement stay in this tab, and survive a reload until you close it. Only the feedback form sends anything.

You are at

An adventure in three levels

Policy decides for the student

Policy decides for the student. That's the usual story, anyway. A syllabus clause permits AI here and forbids it there, and your part is to follow along. This book starts somewhere else, with the decisions you make about AI in your own work, one assignment at a time.

The French theorist Michel de Certeau had a useful way to put this. Institutions set strategies, and people improvise tactics inside them. A policy is a strategy. What you do with a tool late at night, draft due in the morning and a syllabus with nothing to say on the matter, is a tactic, and it belongs to you. The anthropologist Brian Street noticed something close to this about literacy. Older accounts treated it as a skill a person has or lacks. Street saw it as a practice, something people do in particular places, for particular reasons, with something at stake.

So this book asks for practice, which is a different thing from fluency. Fluency is ease with a tool. Operative literacy, the framework's name for what you'll exercise here, is judgment you're willing to stand behind, about when, how, and whether to use the tool, with your reasons attached. You'll move through three levels in order. First you describe what the tool does. Then you look at how it's built and who it leaves at a disadvantage. Last, you decide what this situation calls for: use, limits, or refusal. At the end you'll have a statement of your decision, in your own words, to keep or to share with your instructor. When a new tool or a new assignment comes along, you start again at the first level.

First time through? Read the book, about ten minutes. Its passages are numbered by level: 1 is Describe, 2 is Analyze, 3 is Decide, and 4 is your statement. Back with a new tool or a new assignment? The one-page version asks the same questions at all three levels, in about four minutes. Your answers last only while this tab stays open, so download your statement before you close it.